Skip to content

Eagles Mere Inn is now a proud member of the Historic Hotels of America Learn moreHistoric Hotels of America

(570) 525-3273
Eagles Mere Inn

Sweet Shop

Sleeps
4
Beds
Two queen beds
Building
Main Inn
Pets
Not permitted

Indulge in the sweet nostalgia of Eagles Mere's beloved gathering place. Named for the historic Sweet Shop, where ice cream sundaes and homemade treats have delighted guests for generations. This 2nd-floor room captures the charm of a local favorite. Featuring two queen beds, 24" TV, A/C, a decorative non-working fireplace, and a private bath with tub/shower, it comfortably sleeps four.

Room history

A landmark eatery from the late 1800’s, this ice cream shop in the village center once served baked goods, home-made candies, fountain drawn sodas and much more. Starting in 1938, it had award-winning chocolate covered marshmallows when town personality Bert Fiester was in charge. The Sweet Shop has been a central gathering place in the village forever and a highlight of summering families. Often the employees were a mixture of full-time residents and the children of summer vacationers. All it cost was 5 cents for an ice cream sundae back then! In 2004, the Sweet Shop sold to the nonprofit Eagles Mere Historic Village Inc. (a 501C3 preservation foundation) as part of a plan to restore the entire town center. In 2021, the entire building, which remains essentially unchanged since its earliest years, underwent a sensitive full restoration so that a full daily menu can be served and many future generations can continue to enjoy its unique character and history.